Discussion about this post

User's avatar
John Kirk's avatar

I've been looking for the right example to support my belief that the seasoned music listener can tell the difference between an all-human song and a machine perfect track.

For the past twenty-plus years I collect music on a song by song basis using a well-known major music service. Over the same time period, I have completely lost interest in modern popular music, to the extent that I rarely if ever "audition" a hit song for a spot in my collection.

However, I heard "Tipsy" by Shaboozey a couple of years ago and after two or three plays decided I liked that one and added it. In the past ten years, I could probably count the number of Top 40 songs added on one hand.

You can tell when it's all human, and there's lots of interesting music bubbling underneath the hit machine. Thanks.

Scott Wilkinson's avatar

Nice article! Alas, I doubt many reading this will care, which is not criticism of this article, but society. Most people will think "I still love the song, so what?" You seem to have stopped short of talking more about pitch correction, and how the simple reality is that many (not all but many) well-known singers just aren't good singers. (Or they at least don't have great pitch.) We see this a lot in live performances by people whose studio work we know well, and in the live performance their vocals are...umm...way off-pitch. As in pretty awful-sounding at times. The funny thing is nobody seems to mind this either (it's all just a part of the drunken, crazy party atmosphere of a live show).

All this definitely puts the great recordings of the past into sharp perspective. Just yesterday, I was listening to Chicago's debut 2-LP set, and as I always am, I was just floored by what incredible musicians those guys were. All without computers.

I admit I'm somewhat ambivalent about quantization. I use Logic Pro in my home MIDI studio to write music and I often quantize things. Which might not surprise you until you learn that I'm a Juilliard School graduate and (former) professional musician. I'm also a drummer and percussionist.

It's likely because as a percussionist, while I'm acutely aware of normal human tempo drift, the "holy grail" of percussion is having robotically perfect rhythm. I think I'm a lot more sensitive to tempo drift (even at the millisecond level) in other performances, which is probably why it really bothers me!

Just for fun, the ultimate example of machine-like tempo in humans is in modern drum and bugle corps drumlines. These are young drummers with phenomenal technique who spend thousands of hours practicing to a metronome. They still aren't perfect, but I think you'll agree, they come closer to perfection (re: tempo) than any other human musicians—especially when you see 9 snare drummers sounding like one, even at the 32nd-note level!

https://youtu.be/k3PuLHs0bQE?si=14QtJ_VKZXyUpx3U

13 more comments...

Ready for more?